Retirement planning in 2026 often comes down to one core question: how much of your savings should sit in something predictable versus something that can grow over time? That’s usually where Annuities and Stock accounts enter the conversation. Both can play a useful role in a retirement plan, but many people make avoidable mistakes when deciding how to use them together. This article walks through the most common missteps and what to consider instead.

Why People Combine Annuities and Stock Accounts in the First Place

Annuities are contracts issued by insurance companies that can provide a stream of income, sometimes for life, depending on the contract terms. Stock accounts — whether held in a brokerage account, IRA, or 401(k) — give you ownership in companies and the potential for growth, along with the risk of losing value.

Pairing the two isn’t inherently wrong. The idea is usually to cover essential expenses with steadier income sources while letting stock-based investments work toward longer-term growth. Problems tend to show up not in the strategy itself, but in how people implement it.

Mistake 1: Treating Annuities and Stock Accounts as Interchangeable Tools

One of the biggest errors is assuming these two products serve the same purpose. An annuity is generally designed to address longevity and income stability, while a stock account is generally designed to pursue growth over time. When retirees expect an annuity to behave like a stock account — or expect stock accounts to provide the same predictability as an annuity — the mismatch can lead to disappointment.

Example: Consider a retiree named Carol who purchased a variable annuity expecting it to perform similarly to her old stock portfolio. When market swings affected her annuity’s subaccounts, she was surprised, even though the contract had always carried that risk. Understanding the specific mechanics of your annuity contract before signing can prevent this kind of confusion.

Know What Type of Annuity You Actually Have

Fixed, variable, and indexed annuities behave very differently. A fixed annuity may offer a set interest rate for a period. A variable annuity ties returns to underlying investment subaccounts, which can rise or fall in value. An indexed annuity typically credits interest based on the performance of a market index, often with caps or participation rates that limit both gains and losses. Confusing these categories is a common — and costly — mistake.

Mistake 2: Ignoring Fees, Surrender Charges, and Contract Terms

Annuities often come with surrender periods, which can last anywhere from a few years to over a decade. Withdrawing more than the allowed amount during this period can trigger charges. Some contracts also include mortality and expense fees, administrative fees, or rider costs that reduce overall returns.

Stock accounts have their own cost structures too — trading commissions, fund expense ratios, and advisory fees can all add up. The mistake isn’t having fees; it’s not knowing what they are. Before combining annuities and stock accounts in a retirement plan, ask for a clear breakdown of all costs associated with each product.

Mistake 3: Overlooking Tax Timing

Annuities held outside of retirement accounts grow tax-deferred, meaning you generally don’t pay taxes on the gains until you withdraw them. Stock accounts held in taxable brokerage accounts may generate capital gains taxes each year, depending on how actively they’re managed.

A frequent error is withdrawing from the wrong account at the wrong time, which can create a larger tax bill than necessary. For instance, taking a large annuity withdrawal in the same year you also sell appreciated stock could push you into a higher tax bracket. Coordinating withdrawal timing between annuities and stock accounts can help manage this, though everyone’s tax situation is different and speaking with a tax professional is generally a good idea.

Mistake 4: Putting All Retirement Savings Into One Product Type

Some retirees swing too far in one direction — either placing nearly all their savings into annuities for the sense of security, or keeping everything in stock accounts chasing growth. Both approaches carry tradeoffs.

  • All annuities: This may reduce growth potential and could limit liquidity, since accessing large sums early may trigger fees.
  • All stock accounts: This leaves retirement income fully exposed to market volatility, which can be especially challenging if a downturn happens early in retirement.

Example: James, a retiree in his early sixties, moved his entire 401(k) into a single annuity contract shortly after leaving his job. A few years later, he needed access to a larger sum for a home repair and discovered the surrender charges were steeper than he remembered. Diversifying between annuities and stock accounts — rather than relying entirely on one — may help avoid this kind of situation.

Mistake 5: Not Reassessing Risk Tolerance as You Age

Risk tolerance isn’t static. Someone in their 40s may be comfortable with a stock-heavy portfolio, but that same allocation might feel very different at 68, especially if a market downturn coincides with the start of retirement withdrawals.

A common mistake is setting an allocation between annuities and stock accounts once and never revisiting it. Life changes — health issues, the loss of a spouse, unexpected expenses — can all shift how much market risk feels appropriate. Reviewing your allocation every few years, or after a major life event, is generally a reasonable habit.

The Sequence of Returns Risk Factor

Retirees who withdraw from stock accounts during a market downturn early in retirement may deplete their savings faster than expected, even if the market recovers later. This is sometimes called sequence of returns risk. Some retirees use annuity income to cover essential expenses during volatile years, allow

Additional Educational Resources

Want help comparing your retirement options? Schedule a review or contact us today

Powered by FixedIRAs.com

Helpful Related Resources

Related Reading